In the latest episode of The New Region's GeoSpace podcast, host Mohammed A. Salih sits down with Alex Vatanka, senior fellow at the Middle East Institute, to discuss how the US midterm results are shaping the Iran war, how Tehran is reading the political shift in Washington, and whether diplomacy or further escalation lies ahead.
Vatanka described the mood in Tehran after the Republican defeat as openly celebratory, but he questioned whether Iran has a plan to build on it.
"They have wanted to for months, throughout the war, message directly to the American voter: this is not your war," he said. "The question to ask, if you're sitting in Tehran, is how can you build on this? That's where I don't see anything tangible out of Tehran yet."
He was critical of Supreme Leader Mojtaba Khamenei's claim that it makes no difference who governs in Washington.
"If he believes that, he's gravely mistaken," Vatanka said. "Every American president has had a different take on Iran."
"Is this regime about ideology, about kicking the Americans out of the Middle East? That's open-ended, that means war forever," he said. "Or is it a narrow mission, where Iran puts its national interests first? There, plenty can be done between the US and Iran."
On the hijab, Vatanka said the loosened enforcement should not be read as moderation.
"It was out of necessity that they didn't enforce it, not because they wanted to," he said. "If this war ended next week, they might go back to the streets and enforce it, because the regime fundamentally is not one of compromising."
On Iran's regional position, he said the war has exposed how isolated the country is.
"It didn't capture the world's attention because it [Iran] could call on friends in the region," he said. "It did so by acting recklessly and taking the region hostage. That's not a sustainable model."
Turning to Washington, Vatanka said US President Donald Trump has never made a credible case for the war.
"He keeps saying this is a threat to the United States, that Iranian missiles will rain over American cities, but people just don't believe that," he said. "This was a war of choice."
He said the White House had misjudged Iran's resilience.
"The assumption was that this is a rotten regime, and with one big push, including assassinating the supreme leader, the whole thing would come collapsing down," he said. "They strategically misunderstood the place so badly."
Trump, he said, now faces a choice.
"Double down and risk even more devastation, or bite the bullet and cut a deal with people he doesn't like," he said. With Democrats controlling Congress and his own party restless, Tehran could secure better terms than the 2015 nuclear deal, Vatanka claimed.
On the prospect of a prolonged stalemate under the US blockade, Vatanka cautioned that Iran also has a vote.
"Iran has learned that the best way to get America's attention is to surprise America and go on the offense," he said, citing the recent attack on shipping in the Suez Canal. "This is a very costly affair for the US, many billions of dollars every month."
On what a nuclear deal might look like, he said Iran will refuse to give up enrichment but could agree to dilute its stockpile.
"They're not going to ship that uranium to Russia or China," he said. "But diluting it, yes, exactly what they did back in 2015."
On Israel, he said a government led by Gadi Eisenkot would differ little from Netanyahu's in practice but might open space for quiet understandings.
"This war has shown that Iran cannot destroy Israel, and it has also shown the Israelis they cannot destroy us," he said. "Both sides are in a lose-lose cycle of attrition."
On Russia and China, he said both want the Islamic Republic to survive without wanting to fight for it.
"The Russians use us, let's use them. A lot of it is symbolic," he said. "Tehran's message to the Trump administration is: we're not alone."
As for how far Democrats can constrain Trump, Vatanka said Iran's own conduct will decide.
"If Iran starts killing American soldiers on a larger scale, even the Democrats will have a tough time holding back funds," he said. "So much depends on Iran's actions."